Skip to main content
HavenStone Tax Advisory - HomeHavenStone Tax Advisory logoShield with HavenStone monogram

Entity Structure Matrix for $1M–$10M

Compare S‑Corp, C‑Corp, and Partnership using an apples‑to‑apples model of payroll/SE layers, corporate tax, and shareholder dividends. Use this to frame your strategy session.

Sole Prop / Partnership
$29,808
S‑Corporation
$13,770
C‑Corporation
$79,702

Business

Household wages reduce the remaining threshold before Additional Medicare applies.

Thresholds

Additional Medicare threshold: $200,000

Update the wage base annually when the IRS publishes the new amount.

C‑Corp assumptions

Sole Prop / Partnership
SE earnings (92.35% of profit): $277,050
OASDI (12.4%, capped)$21,080
Medicare (2.9%, uncapped)$8,034
Additional Medicare (0.9%)$693
Total considered
$29,808
S-Corporation
Employer FICA$6,885
Employee FICA + Addl Med$6,885

Employee Additional Medicare uses the remaining threshold after household wages.

Total considered
$13,770
C-Corporation
Corp tax (21% + state)$44,100
W-2 FICA (combined)$13,770
Shareholder tax on dividends$21,832
Total considered
$79,702

S‑Corp vs. Sole Prop

$16,038

Payroll/SE angle only; excludes income tax & §199A.

C‑Corp vs. Sole Prop

-$49,895

Includes corp tax + FICA + dividends under your assumptions.

Quick notes:

  • Only **OASDI** is capped at the wage base; **Medicare is uncapped**.
  • Additional Medicare (0.9%) applied using **remaining threshold after household wages**.
  • Planner excludes full individual income tax, §199A/QBI limits, NIIT on pass‑through, FUTA/SUTA, and local payroll taxes.

Get the full matrix (PDF + spreadsheet)

Includes assumptions, pros/cons by scenario, and a documentation checklist for S-Corp reasonable compensation.

Common questions

Short answers based on how the planner actually models payroll layers, NIIT, and state corporate tax.

OASDI (12.4% split employer/employee) is capped at the wage base you enter (e.g., $170,000). Only wages are subject to OASDI; it doesn’t apply to S-Corp distributions or C-Corp dividends.
The 0.9% Additional Medicare applies to wages above the remaining threshold after household W-2 wages. The tool shows a $200,000 default threshold for Single (and higher thresholds for MFJ).
Generally no. Owner-employees must take reasonable W-2 compensation (subject to payroll taxes). Distributions above reasonable comp are typically not subject to SE tax.
Use the state corporate tax rate input to include your state’s C-Corp tax. The card summarizes the combined corporate layer in the C-Corporation column.
For C-Corps, you can toggle “Apply NIIT 3.8% on dividends.” The planner excludes NIIT on pass-through by design (see notes).
The quick planner excludes full individual income tax, 199A/QBI limits, NIIT on pass-through, FUTA/SUTA, and local payroll taxes (see the notes box below the comparison).
A PDF and spreadsheet of the full Entity Matrix: assumptions, pros/cons by scenario, a reasonable-compensation checklist, and advisor notes.
Yes. The calculator and downloadable materials are free.

Related video

The “$1M+ Structure” Quick Take

If your business is past $1M in revenue, your entity structure could be costing you $50K–$100K+ every year. Learn when to upgrade to an S-Corp or C-Corp and how to fix it.

Editorial review

Reviewed for tax accuracy

Educational tax content prepared by HavenStone Advisory and reviewed for technical accuracy. It is not individualized tax, legal, accounting, investment, or financial advice. Rules can change, and your facts matter, so confirm decisions with your CPA, attorney, or tax advisor before acting.

Reviewed by Mia Anne Pham Reeves, CPA

See our editorial policy or report a correction.

Verify reviewer CPA license through TSBPA

Primary references

Review standard

  • Primary-source references checked where rule-specific claims are made.
  • Article scope limited to educational information unless a client engagement exists.
  • Time-sensitive tax rules labeled with published, updated, or reviewed dates.

Turn your entity model into a tax plan

Bring your numbers and get a focused, CPA-led session to choose S-Corp vs C-Corp vs LLC, set a defensible owner salary, align payroll/SE tax and dividends, and leave with a clear 12-month implementation checklist.